StudyPebble

Punctuation within a sentence

Choose among commas, semicolons, colons, and dashes based on what each side of the punctuation is.

Standard English ConventionsReading and Writing
Practice punctuation within a sentence free

What the SAT actually asks

You choose the right mark for a spot inside a sentence, where the choices are often a comma, a semicolon, a colon, a dash, or no punctuation. The decision comes from structure, not from style. A semicolon needs a complete sentence on each side. A colon needs a complete sentence before it and introduces an explanation, an example, or a list. A pair of dashes can set off a nonessential element the way a pair of commas does, but the marks must match.

Punctuation questions of this kind usually make up about 1 to 3 of the 54 reading and writing questions.

Where students lose points

How to attack these questions

  1. 1Read what is on each side of the blank and label each as either a complete sentence or not.
  2. 2Eliminate the semicolon and the colon immediately if what comes before the mark is not a complete sentence.
  3. 3If the sentence sets off an interrupting phrase, make sure the opening and closing marks are the same type.

Example questions

Written for this skill, with the answer explained. 48 more are in the app.

Try one
Punctuation within a sentence
Real question

After three overtime periods that left both teams barely able to ______ the referees finally called the match a draw.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

Easier

The town rebuilt the old______ stone bridge exactly as it had stood for two centuries.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

  • A) old,
  • B) old:
  • C) old ✓
  • D) old;

Why: "Stone" names the kind of bridge and forms a unit with it, and "old" then describes that whole unit, so these are cumulative adjectives: you cannot say "stone and old bridge" or reverse them, and no mark belongs between them, which makes old correct. Writing old, inserts the comma that only coordinate adjectives take. Writing old; would require an independent clause on each side of the semicolon. Writing old: would require a complete clause before the colon and an explanation or list after it, and a noun phrase supplies neither.

Easier

The overnight survey, conducted along a stretch of river that had not been formally studied in over a decade, recorded otters, herons nesting in numbers nobody on the team had predicted______ and one very startled beaver that nearly capsized the canoe.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

  • A) predicted:
  • B) predicted, ✓
  • C) predicted
  • D) predicted;

Why: The survey recorded three things, "otters," "herons nesting in numbers nobody on the team had predicted," and "one very startled beaver," so the comma before the final "and" is required and predicted, is correct. A semicolon in predicted; would be right only if the items carried commas inside them, and none of these do. A colon in predicted: cannot appear mid-list, since a colon introduces a list only after a complete independent clause. Leaving it as predicted fuses the long second item to the third with no separator.

Harder

Racing to catch the last ferry of the ______ the two of us left our bags behind on the dock.

  • A) night which was unusually cold
  • B) night—which was unusually cold
  • C) night, which was unusually cold
  • D) night, which was unusually cold, ✓

Why: The clause describing the night is nonrestrictive, so it needs a comma on each side, and the closing comma also marks the end of the whole introductory phrase before the subject "the two of us," which is what night, which was unusually cold, gives you. Writing night, which was unusually cold opens the interrupter with a comma but never closes it, so the modifier runs into the main clause. Writing night which was unusually cold drops both commas, turning supplementary information into a restrictive clause and leaving no boundary before the subject. Writing night—which was unusually cold opens with a dash, so the two ends of the interrupter do not match and the introductory phrase is still left unclosed.

Questions students ask

When do I use a colon on the SAT?

Use a colon only when the words before it form a complete sentence, and when what follows explains, illustrates, or lists what that sentence set up. What follows the colon does not have to be a complete sentence.

Can a dash replace a comma?

A pair of dashes can set off a nonessential element just as a pair of commas can, and a single dash can introduce an explanation the way a colon does. The rule the SAT enforces is consistency: you cannot open with a dash and close with a comma.

How do I choose between a comma and a semicolon?

Check whether both sides are complete sentences. Two complete sentences with no conjunction require a semicolon. If one side is a fragment or a modifying phrase, a comma is the right mark.

Drill this skill until it is automatic

Questions on punctuation within a sentence alone, with explanations on every one, and the app tracks which ones you keep missing.

Start practicing

Guides that cover this

Other Standard English Conventions skills