StudyPebble

SAT Verb Tense Consistency

Tense questions look like they are about grammar rules, but they are usually about context. The correct tense is whichever one matches the timeline the rest of the passage has already set, so the answer almost always comes from a verb in a nearby sentence rather than from a rule.

The rule

Match the tense of the surrounding sentences unless the passage gives a specific time marker that requires a shift.

Start by finding the tense of the surrounding verbs. If the paragraph is describing a historical event and the verbs around the blank are past tense, the blank is past tense too. If the paragraph is describing what a theory holds or what a text does, the verbs will be present, and the blank follows. Consistency is the default expectation.

Departures from that default need a reason in the passage. A time marker such as in 1927, last summer, or currently can justify a shift. In: the museum now displays the collection, which curators assembled over two decades, the present and past tenses coexist because the sentence describes two different times, and the words now and over two decades mark them.

The past perfect, formed with had plus a past participle, is for an event that happened before another past event. In: by the time the team arrived, the equipment had already been unloaded, the unloading came first. If only one past event is being described, the past perfect is wrong, and the SAT offers it precisely to see whether you will pick the more complicated-sounding form.

Present perfect, formed with has or have plus a past participle, covers something that began in the past and continues or remains relevant. Researchers have studied the site for thirty years implies the study is ongoing. Researchers studied the site for thirty years implies it is finished. The choice between them depends on what the passage says about whether the situation continues.

Practically, never answer a tense question from the underlined sentence alone. Read the sentence before and the sentence after, note their verbs, and match unless the passage gives you an explicit reason to shift. The rule is the tiebreaker, and the context is the evidence.

The trap

Selecting the past perfect when only one past event is being described, because had sounds more formal than the simple past.

Try it

Try one
Real question

Seeds of the Judean date palm recovered from a desert fortress sat in a drawer for forty years. In 2005 a researcher planted three of them, and within weeks one ______ .

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

Engineers opened the Vanmoor sluice in April 1937 and closed it for good that September. Before the first gate ever moved, though, upstream farmers ______ the same marsh for eleven years with windmills and hand-dug ditches, work the official history credits entirely to the sluice.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

  • A) were draining
  • B) have drained
  • C) had drained ✓
  • D) drained

Why: The farmers' eleven years of work happened before a specific past event, the gate opening, so the past perfect "had drained" is required. "were draining" is wrong because its past progressive form leaves the eleven years unfinished at the moment the gate moved. "have drained" is wrong because its present perfect form runs the drainage up to now rather than up to 1937. "drained" is wrong because its simple past form loses the sequence that "before the first gate ever moved" establishes.

Practice more of these free

Questions students ask

When do I use had plus a verb?

Only when one past event happened before another past event, and you need to show the order. If the passage describes a single past event, the simple past is correct and the past perfect is an error.

What tense should I use when writing about a book or a study?

Present tense is standard for what a text says or argues, as in the essay argues that the policy failed. Past tense is used for the events being described and for what researchers did. Both can appear in one sentence for that reason.

Guides that cover this